The Finance Committee Can Say No — and Right Now, It Should
Watch the meeting: [Finance Committee, November 18, 2026 https://youtu.be/0GTiNEKc_04?si=dPMCnMqxJFw9la9Z&t=2079]. Public comment begins at about 34:43; the aldermen's remarks follow at 36:53.
Last week Nashua homeowners learned their property taxes are going up 9.5%. Nobody told the public to expect that. The bills come due December 22, three days before Christmas.
One week later, on Wednesday night, the Finance Committee met to approve contracts over $25,000, as the City's purchasing policy requires. One resident, Laura Colquhoun, spoke by Zoom during public comment. She asked a direct question and raised a serious concern. Nobody answered the question. The way the committee reacted to her concern should worry every taxpayer in this city.
What Laura asked
Laura made two points.
The first was a simple question. The agenda listed about $5 million in purchases "funded by a bond" from the capital outlay account. Laura asked whether that money was coming out of the roughly $12 million already sitting in that account on the City's books, or whether it meant new bond money. "If somebody could answer me, I would appreciate it," she said.
The second point was about the big picture. This year the Board of Aldermen approved about $125 million in new bonds. About $34 million approved in 2025 is still open. Nashua's total approved bond debt is now around $844 million. Some of those bonds haven't been sold yet. "Are we aiming to get a billion dollars outstanding?" she asked. With a 9.5% increase hitting residents, she said, somebody has to start cutting back, and the Finance Committee should look at the City's total obligations, not one purchase at a time.
That's a reasonable request. It's the committee's job.
Did anyone answer her? No.
Alderman Sullivan spoke first. He said he wasn't sure his remarks were "related to that point," and then he described an accounting question of his own.
Sullivan's remarks didn't answer Laura's question. They backed her up. A sitting member of the committee walked into the meeting unable to tell whether the money was in the account. His figures were two months old. He had asked the CFO and gotten no answer, and the committee voted anyway. If an alderman can't get a clear answer to "is the money there, or are we borrowing it?", a resident at home has no chance. That was exactly Laura's point.
Chairman Klee came closest to a response. She said the numbers Laura cited were probably "bonds that have not been sold yet." Alderman Clemens added that "they might be waiting for these contracts to be passed before we sell them." Look at what that means. If the City waits for the Finance Committee to approve contracts before it sells the bonds, then the committee's approval is the step that sends Nashua out to borrow, at today's interest rates. That's the reverse of the committee having no say. It's the moment the debt becomes real.
Nobody gave Laura a yes or a no on whether the $5 million was cash on hand or new borrowing. Nobody offered to get her an answer in writing. Nobody said anything about the $844 million.
"Already approved" is not the same as "still affordable"
Chairman Klee's main response to the public was this:
"What comes before the finance committee has already been approved through the budget committee… we don't approve things that haven't been already approved through the budget process."
She summed it up this way: "The budget committee puts the money in the account. Finance writes the check."
If that's how the Finance Committee sees itself, it's describing a rubber stamp.
Take the Capital Equipment Reserve Fund (CERF). Each year the Budget Review Committee approves a list of equipment due for replacement, mostly for Fire, Police and Public Works. Many items on that list don't reach the Finance Committee for two years or longer. By then prices have changed, interest rates have changed, and the City's finances have changed. This year, taxpayers' finances changed by 9.5%.
Chairman Klee knows this. Near the end of the meeting she recalled how she and Alderman Clemens had been frustrated when items took so long to get through the Board of Public Works and then the Finance Committee that bids came in "double the price of what they were." She said herself that time changes what things cost. The same is true of what taxpayers can afford.
The purchasing policy requires Finance Committee approval for every contract over $25,000. That rule exists for a reason. An approval you aren't allowed to withhold isn't an approval. If the committee's only job is to sign whatever the Budget Review Committee put on a list in 2024 or 2025, we don't need a committee. A clerk could do it.
The kitchen-renovation test
Every household in Nashua understands this.
Say that in your family budget you decide to renovate the kitchen in 18 months, because you expect to be able to afford it by then. Then the date arrives. Food, fuel, insurance and medical bills have all gone up, and the car needs a repair you can't put off. So you do the sensible thing and push the kitchen back. It's still a good idea. It just isn't the right time.
An earlier decision isn't a promise you have to keep after your circumstances change. A responsible household looks again before it spends. A responsible Finance Committee should too. It should be able to say: things have changed since this was budgeted, our financial outlook is different, and we're deferring this, or we're paying cash instead of borrowing.
Borrowing costs more than it used to
Debt isn't free, and it's getting more expensive.
When Nashua sold $59.6 million in bonds in October 2024, it got an interest rate of 3.4%. The cost estimates for roughly $100 million in newly approved bonds assume about 4%, and rates may keep rising. Every percentage point matters. On $100 million of 20-year debt, a single extra point adds roughly $10 million in interest over the life of the bonds, all of it paid by Nashua property owners.
The City already had a plan for this. In 2024 it formed an ad hoc debt committee, which recommended borrowing no more than $25–30 million a year and paying cash for projects under about $2.5–3 million instead of bonding them. The City hasn't kept to that plan in any year since. It sold $59.7 million in bonds in October 2024 and $44.5 million in October 2025, both well over the cap, and it has kept bonding small projects.
The Finance Committee sees every contract that spends this money. It's the last place to stop and ask whether the City should still be doing this.
The mood in the room
Residents watching at home should notice how the committee received Laura's comments. She is a longtime watchdog of City finances. She had done her homework, including a Right-to-Know request for bond information. She asked a direct question about millions of dollars. The committee didn't treat it with any urgency. Nobody spoke to her. The members explained their procedures, joked about "buy three trucks, get one free," and adjourned to laughter.
Nine days before Thanksgiving, with bills due the week of Christmas, many families in this city aren't laughing.
One thing did go right. Laura was able to speak remotely. Residents who can't get to City Hall because of disability, illness, caregiving or work should be able to do that at every Board and committee meeting, every time. Access to public meetings shouldn't depend on being able to walk into the chamber.
What the Finance Committee should do now
1 Answer Laura's question in writing before the next meeting: was the roughly $5 million approved on November 18 paid from existing cash, from bonds already sold, or from bonds still to be sold?
2 Put current balances in every packet. Each bond-funded or CERF item should show the account's balance as of the week of the meeting, not 60 days earlier, and say whether the money is cash, sold bonds or unsold authorizations.
3 Show the cost of borrowing. For any contract that triggers a bond sale, show the expected interest rate and the total cost, interest included.
4 Re-check older approvals. Any capital item budgeted more than 12 months ago should come back with an updated cost and a short explanation of why it can't wait.
5 Be willing to say no. Defer, re-bid, or pay cash. The committee has the authority to do this, and the purchasing policy gives it this job for a reason.
6 Offer remote public comment at every meeting.
The Finance Committee isn't just there to write checks. It's the last place in City Hall where someone can ask whether we can still afford this, and on Wednesday night nobody asked.
Laura Colquhoun asked. She deserves an answer, and so does every taxpayer opening a tax bill this December.